Listener Reviews

This show is awesome! I love all the different guest host and their takes. Totally worth going for the paid feed, tons of content!

I’d love for you to watch the Accused: guilty or innocent? or Accused: did i do it? series on Hulu! There’s also a series called Relentless that would be another great recap!

Love this podcast and all of Amye’s work. Witty and insightful as always

Started listening a couple months ago and by far my favorite podcast in a long time.

He was addicted to pills not coke. Opiates. Powder top makes zero sense.

THE WILLARD PREACHER. I went to Penn State from 2009-2013, and it sounds like the same guy you mentioned on the Andrea Yates recap.

Going through Cancer treatment now, and I love listening to Amy, Becca, Amanda and her other hosts. It’s a welcome relief, thank you!

Murder She Watched is my go to podcast. Amye says all the things I am thinking when watching a True Crime documentary. I hope she does an episode about Evil Influencer on Netflix. Cannot wait to hear her commentary on both of those women.

💜

I recently discovered this podcast and I love it! My only feedback-I feel like the host interrupts her guests a lot. I have binged a large portion of the episodes and it is pretty consistent interruptions.

Host Amye Archer (along with her incredible rotation of guests like Amanda, Becca, and Kyla) provides brilliant, energetic, and empathetic deep dives into the true crime documentaries and series we're all binging. Amye is totally and completely relatable; she makes you laugh out loud. It genuinely feels like you're hanging out with your smartest, funniest friends who are just as obsessed with the case as you are.

Finally…it like I have someone to discuss all the documentaries I watch! Strikes the perfect balance of empathy, humor, intrigue, and opinion. Also: HANDS DOWN, the best podcast name ever. I’m annoyed I didn’t think of it first.

New favorite podcast! These girls are hysterical I’ve never laughed so hard about murder. The staircase episodes are so good! I love the imitation of Michael with the pipe!

I am a big fan of podcasts but this is the very first one I have ever subscribed and paid for. Love that the host is intelligent yet humble and someone I’d want to be friends with. Fun to listen to yet always respectful of victims.

This podcast feels like you’re just talking to your friends about the documentary you both just watched. I can’t tell you how many times I have talked back now thinking I’m part of the conversation. I accidentally binged all the available episodes in 2 days so now I wait!

Great conversation and a lot of good points. Having grown up with a narcissist mother, the documentary was very triggering for me. I do feel like Kendra is a narcissist with sociopathic tendencies. She was jealous of her own daughter. I lived it with my mother but thankfully there wasn't technology when I was a teenager. She flirted with my dates and would tell them bad things about me. Kendra should have gotten more jail time!

Love hearing your takes!

That’s all. I just love listening.

This show is the highlight of my week. I whisper Amye’s name in my heart a thousand times. She is there, but I can’t stop crying. 😂😂💗💗💗

Love these recaps so much that I’ve been using them as a guide on what to watch so that I can come back and listen to the recap. The Bakersfield 3 doc was phenomenal. I also watched knowing absolutely nothing, and I was blown away. I was SO glad Amy and her guest had a similar reaction and really did it justice. One small piece that I read about the case afterwards that I found helpful- the DA needed to charge Baylee too because so much of their case against MQ relied on MV’s testimony, so discrediting that would have made it harder to convict MQ. I still think Baylee is a victim both when she was there and now.

I look forward to new episodes, but nearly all of them are marked for subscribers only. Will probably stop checking for updates.

I am so glad I stumbled on this show. The host’s Michael Peterson impression is amazing! It makes me laugh so hard. Keep up the good work.

Great takes and honest POV’s

I LOVE Amye Archer, I love little miss recap and I’m so happy she now has a true crime podcast. Even with sensitive topics that I’d usually avoid, her delivery makes the case tolerable and brings awareness in a way that I appreciate.Although I’m in my 30s, she very much reminds me of how it was watching true crime documentaries with my mom and because she has past some years ago, it’s a nice refreshing feeling when listening to her take on these cases. I find her humor relatable and hope she continues putting episodes out here and little miss recap. Love you Amye! And your choice in guests are always superb