Listener Reviews

I really like the show and just found it because of my obsession with The Crash. I think Mackenzie’s parents are no great shakes, but have you considered she’s just a bad seed?

If you love true crime documentaries, this podcast is an absolute must-listen! The hosts expertly recap and analyze each documentary, providing insightful commentary, thoughtful context, and just the right amount of suspense. I appreciate how they break down the details, highlight key moments, and offer their own perspectives, making each episode both informative and engaging. The production quality is consistently high, and the pacing ensures every episode flies by. Five stars for a show that truly enhances the experience of murder documentary fandom! Highly recommend to anyone who can’t get enough of true crime docs.

I love this podcast. Oftentimes I don’t want to watch a documentary or series but I always enjoy Ayme and friends break it down.

Love everything you do Amye 😊❤️

I wish I was a Libra soI could be a Libra detective

I love listening to Amye talk about everything! I don’t usually watch the docs first but I’ll listen and if I’m intrigued then I’ll go back and watch. I love the overviews mixed with some humor.

This is my newest obsession. I love this podcast, honestly I wish there were more episodes. I really enjoy true crime, but not everyone in my life is as enthusiastic about the topic. This podcast allows you to take part in the discussions about interesting cases and view points without having to leaving your house, and I love that for us.

Hands down the best podcast and podcaster out there! I will listen to anything amye archer puts out- it's like listening to and talking with a friend

This is my 3rd rewatch of Tiger King, and I also go back and forth on whether or not Carole killed Don. My honest opinion, I don’t think she did. I think her weird behavior is because she’s not that sad that he’s gone as opposed to her being guilty. I also think she’s so removed from their marriage being that she was unhappy and it’s been so long that she appears emotionless talking about it. My other theory is that she knows he was planning on hiding out in Costa Rica, so she’s not mourning his death because she might know he’s alive. Just my thoughts, love your show!

If you don’t listen to anything else, at least listen to Amye’s recaps of Murdaugh: Death in the Family and The Staircase. Chef’s kiss!

I’m loving this one so much. I rewatched it because of the pod. Also became a subscriber because of Tiger King-so good

The best pod hosts for navigating the nuthouse of true crime tv & film. Relatable, lovely women of a certain age yapping about the crimes we all collectively solve from our couches.

My all time FAVORITE podcast! I cannot get enough

So happy to have found this gem. Amye and her various co hosts do an excellent job solving these crimes from their couches! It is very refreshing to hear their takes on the documentaries and such I highly recommend. Keep going ladies and gents there are more crimes out there to solve and thank you for taking us all with you to do so!

I found Amye on Little Miss Recap and she is brings that energy and personality to crime. All of her cohosts are fantastic and fit in with Amye and her listeners. Love love love this podcast.

Terrific podcast

…is to take a shot every time Amye says “dark”, “this is darker”, or “it’s about to get dark”. The only problem is, I may end up unconscious. Otherwise, it’s great.

I love Amye and all of her different co-hosts! Amye does a great job of making the show fun but serious when it needs to be and most importantly making the victim the center of the story. Even if they have to do more research. Love love love!

I love this podcast! I’d listen to this group of women read a dictionary! They make everything funny and relatable.

Amye and her co-hosts have such great chemistry and she chooses just the right person for each episode! Great Couch Detective community too!!

Amye, Kyla, Becca, and the rest of the MSW cohosts hit it out of the park every time! The strike the perfect mix of humor and respect for serious stories. If you love murder shows and smart recaps, this is the podcast for you!

Love the deep dives, and you’ve been picking the BEST shows and documentaries to watch. It’s great to finally get caught up on certain famous cases I hadn’t dove into yet.Thank you Amye, Amanda, Becca, Shabnam, Kyla, et al. for this fun new addition to my podcast listening!

This show is great!!!! It’s like watching a show with my besties and discussing it!

Amye and her friends are fantastic to “hang out” with. I have been known to watch things just because they are discussing it. They are so fun, engaging, and informative, I’ll listen to whatever they release. Keep it up ladies!