Listener Reviews

This has become one of my favorite podcasts, and my #1 listened to on Apple! I started listening back in September ‘25 and I literally subscribed after only one episode- I thought “these are my people” lol. Amye and her pals are always a treat to listen to and I really appreciate the blend of factual info, relatable opinions, and humor, and of course respect to the victims. Love it!

I will listen to anything Amye does, but nearly all of the episodes are behind a paywall. Throw us poor fans an episode every once in awhile!

If you lost your favorite comedy true crime recap show a few years ago, this is a great replacement. The cases are handled with kindness and respect but a dash of fun.

I love this podcast, and the structure of how they are always going to “solve the case”! The hosts are always compassionate and kind hearted while still giving a little levity from dark content. Nothing ever feels over the top or forced. They don’t go off topic too much, which is nice! I also appreciate how Amye does monthly themes of cases. She covers well known cases as well as true crime docs that have literally just been released. Never thought I would laugh so much at an episode covering Chris Watts (in a positive way).

This podcast has everything: Michael Peterson impressions, rants about CapriSun, a Durst rating scale, and that thing where someone is always quoting Scott Peterson’s voicemail.

Enjoy every episode especially the Staircase and Murdaugh!

I listen to Amye on her other podcast: Little Miss Recap which covers reality television. I love my trash TV, but I’m also a Gen X couch detective from way back. I’ve been reading true crime since I was a kid and I eventually studied forensic psychology. I love listening to Amye and her fellow hosts talk about all the idiot to murderers while also showing great empathy for the victims and their families. Plus her Michael Peterson impression is spot on. Come for the murder, stay for the love of soldier top and all the other tops to come!

Just perfect. True crime recaps with intelligent commentary and the appropriate dose of compassion and humor. Darn it-will have to join the patreon soon because I’m addicted apparently.

This podcast is so refreshing. It’s not your usual sensationalized true crime podcast so if you’re looking for something different and not so heavy to scratch that itch this is the podcast for you.

love it

I can't get enough! Amye and her pod besties keeping murder light while keeping it real. I am not alone-this "ladies of a certain age" community gets me. So glad I found you all :)!

Thank you for being a fellow couch detective. Love the content!

I love this podcast. It’s great! They bring great levity to something that is so sad .

I highly recommend!

Every time Amy(e) mentions her Gram, I just smile. Her stories remind me so much of my grandma ❤️

All the ladies on the podcast are thoughtful and caring. It really shows in their work. Great job Amye and team!

Truly the best!

Enjoy every episode; the perfect mix of recap and commentary.

Amye is a rare talent! Funny and intelligent- anything she reviews is then better than the original! It’s a fun review of true crime stories. Keep up the good work! :)

It’s perfect for “women of a certain age” and anyone else interested in true crime!

Love Amye and all of her impersonations! Always has great co-hosts!

The accents and nicknames made the Murdaugh coverage a little hard to listen to. Your commentary is interesting and entertaining without the over the top attempt at comedy

Amye and company are hysterical and I highly enjoy this podcast. Even subscribed! Especially love the scripted series content like the Staircase and Murdoch. For the 48 Hours, Dateline, etc. I find that I can listen to episodes and not even watch the tv because the team thoroughly (and enjoyably) covers the content. Thanks ladies!

Love both Little Miss Recap and Murder She Watched! These shows recap a lot of the same stuff I’m interested in, I always like the hosts’ takes, and I often laugh out loud (when appropriate!). Love the show, keep it up 💗✨