Episodes

Amye is joined by Becca to talk about The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story (HULU, 2026) When high school student Cassie Stoddart was found stabbed to death in a house on the outskirts of Pocatello, Idaho, the community...

Amye is joined by Kyla to recap I Love You, Now Die: The Commonwealth V Michelle Carter (HBO, 2019) TRIGGER WARNING: We discuss suicide and suicidal ideation in this episode. Please call or text 988 (the crisis hotline) if yo...

Amye is joined by Kyla for a deep dive on Pam Hupp– everyone’s least favorite sociopath. This is the kind of content you can enjoy if you sign up for Murder Club! Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus conten...

Amye is joined by Amanda to chat about and recap Lifetime’s Accused: The Karen Read Story This is bad. We watch it so you don’t have to. Want more content? Join Murder Club and get this episode ad free and bonus content by si...

Amye is joined by Kyla to discuss the wildest Dateline ever where Keith Morrison faces off against Leah Askey in the Pam Hupp murder investigation. You can watch the episode here: https://www.nbcnews.com/dateline/video/full-e...

Amye is joined by Karen to discuss Handsome Devil: Charming Killer, which aired on Paramount Plus in 2026. TRIGGER WARNING: We talk a lot about domestic violence and violence against women. Please listen with care. A three-pa...

Amye is joined by Kyla to chat about Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart (Netflix, 2026) TRIGGER WARNING: In this episode we discuss rape and child sexual assault Elizabeth Smart recounts her kidnapping at age 14 from her Utah home th...

Amye is joined by Ashley to discuss The Cult Behind the Killer: The Andrea Yates Story TRIGGER WARNING: This episode talks about suicidal ideation and the death of children. Please listen with caution. This three-part docuser...

Amye is joined by Becca to dissect and discuss the second season of the 2023 Netflix documentary Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal The Murdaughs are a prominent family in South Carolina, until a fatal boating accident begi...

Amye is joined by Becca to dissect and discuss the first season of the 2023 Netflix documentary Murdaugh Murders: A Southern Scandal The Murdaughs are a prominent family in South Carolina, until a fatal boating accident begin...

Amye is joined by Karen to discuss the 2023 Apple TV docuseries, John Lennon: Murder WIthout a Trial This documentary features exclusive eyewitness interviews and previously unseen crime scene photos of cultural icon John Len...

Amye is joined by Brian Crooks, host of MAFS Virgin, to discuss the 2025 Netflix documentary, Sean Combs: The Reckoning CONTENT WARNING: This episode talks a lot about rape and sexual assault. A revealing look at Sean Combs' ...

Amye is joined by retired FBI agent and true crime podcaster (and author!) Jodene Weber to chat about the verdict in the Brian Walshe case. CONTENT WARNING: We discuss dismemberment of a body in this episode. Listen to Jodi’s...

Amye is joined by Kyla to chat about The Rocky Mountain Mortician, which is a docuseries you can find on ID or HBO. This docuseries examines the 2012 murder of Colorado funeral director Byron Griffy, revealing a complex case ...

Amye and Amanda recap and review the 2024 Netflix documentary, Cold Case: Who Killed JonBenet Ramsey? Please note this is a replay from Little Miss Recap (my reality tv podcast) TRIGGER WARNING: This episode contains discussi...

Amye is joined by Shabnam to discuss The Carman Family Deaths (Netflix, 2025) CONTENT WARNING: Please note we discuss suicide in this episode. Please text or call the suicide hotline at 988 if you or someone you know is strug...

Who is the worst Peterson? We think we have figured it out! Amye is joined by Kyla to discuss Drew Peterson and his crimes. When 23-year-old mother of four Stacy Peterson vanishes, suspicion lands on her police officer husban...

Amye and Kyla are going on an Unsolved Mysteries journey and you’re invited to come along! We are starting with volume 1, episode 1: Mystery on the Rooftop, which cover the mysterious disappearance of Rey Rivera. CONTENT WARN...

Amye is joined by friend of the pod, Mary Payne Gilbert from Pink Shade to discuss Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers (Netflix, 2025) TRIGGER WARNINGS for this episode include: sexual violence, rape. Aileen Wuornos remains a...

Amye is joined by Becca to discuss the 2025 Netflix Documentary, The Perfect Neighbor A seemingly minor neighbourhood dispute in Florida escalates into deadly violence. Police bodycam footage and investigative interviews expo...

Amye is joined by Kyla to discuss the 2025 Netflix documentary: My Father, The BTK Killer TRIGGER WARNING: We talk about suicide, sexual abuse, and torture in this episode. Kerri Rawson was 26 years old when her father, Denni...

Amye is joined by Tess Brigham to discuss the 2025 documentary: Death in Apartment 603: What Happened to Ellen Greenberg? CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains discussion of suicide and self harm. If you are struggling, ther...

Amye is joined by Kyla to discuss 20/20 S43:EP3 Over My Dead Body (Adelson Case) We go back to the very beginning– the 20/20 which detailed Dan Markel’s murder and subsequent investigation and arrest of his killers. “A Florid...

Amye is joined by Amanda to discuss the 2017 Netflix true crime documentary, Abducted in Plain Sight CONTENT WARNING: This episode contains discussion of child sexual abuse. In 1974, 12-year-old Jan Broberg was abducted from ...