A Toxic Love Story (Netflix, 2026): CraigsList, Revenge, and Disney Adults

Amye is joined by Kyla to recap and review the Netflix documentary, A Toxic Love Story.

The film unravels the infamous real-life Anaheim Craigslist case involving a newlywed U.S. Marshal, his new wife, and his ex-fiancée, exploring a twisted revenge plot and a sophisticated web of lies.

JOIN MURDER CLUB

Want more content? Join the club for ad-free episodes and bonus deep-dives.

• Patreon: patreon.com/murdershewatched
• Newsletter: Stay updated with The Detective’s Lounge (it's free!): murdershewatched.substack.com

SUPPORT THE SHOW & MERCH

• Merch: Grab your gear at littlemissrecap.threadless.com
• Cameo: Get a personal shoutout from me (or "Michael Peterson"): cameo.com/amyearcher
• Reality TV: Catch my other show, Little Miss Recap, at littlemissrecap.com

CONNECT WITH US

• Instagram: @murdershewatchedpod
• Facebook Group: Couch Detectives Community
• YouTube: Watch the recaps
• 
  
• Email: murdershewatchedpod@gmail.com

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.